Limit Sets of Punctured-Surface Groups.

The pictures below were generated with a new version of lset.f which enumerates limit points by the infinite word algorithm for general terminal function groups representing a surface with at least one puncture (so that the group is free).

The choice of generators is based on the theory described in

I. Kra, Horocyclic coordinates for Riemann surfaces and moduli spaces. I: Teichmüller and Riemann spaces of Kleinian group, J.A.M.S., v. 3, 1990, 499-578.

Free on two parabolic generators

We use PARI notation to describe the generators

a = [ 1 , 2 ; 0 , 1]
b = [ 1 , 0 ; mu, 1]

This means:

Nearly Fuchsian: mu = 1.91 +.05 i
Click to enlarge

The blue arrows label certain limit points with their associated infinite word. Keep reading to learn what the notation means. The red curves are flowlines associated to certain elements of the group, flowing from the repelling fixed point to the attractive fixed point.

Notation for labelling limit points by infinite words:

Infinite words are indicated by

x1 x2 x3 x4 ... xn [ y1 y2 ... ym ]

where each letter is a generator or an inverse and the word in between brackets is repeated without end. Thus, if z is the attractive fixed point of y1 .... ym then the associated limit point is

x1 x2 ... xn (z)

A capital letter always represents the inverse of the generator represented by the corresponding small case letter.

Near other main cusp of Riley slice: mu = 0.05 + 0.93 i
Click to enlarge

Maskit-Kra's T(1,2) (twice-punctured tori)

These are free on three generators:

a = [ 1 + mu1*mu2 , 2*mu1 ; mu2/2 , 1]
b = [ 1 , 2 ; 0 , 1]
c = [ 1 , 0 ; 2 , 1]

Side-pairing

The generators given above are side-pairing transformations on a certain fundamental region bounded by continuous arcs. We number the sides and label the side-pairing transformations according to the following diagram:

Side-pairing for twice-punctured torus
mu1 = mu2 = -.08 + 1.95 i:
Click to enlarge

Same Picture: Focus on Bottom Half

Same Picture: Invariant domain filled

Relevant artwork

It should be emphasized that this algorithm draws these sets as continuous curves, not as unions of circles. To see the curve-drawing process clearly, one must view the original PostScript file via a previewer such as ghostview. Click (or shift-click in Netscape) on the image below to load the corresponding PostScript file. It is a small piece of the above limit set, namely, all limit points corresponding to infinite words beginning with aa. Note: this is a 0.6 Mbyte compressed PostScript file (.eps.gz).

A piece of the previous limit set

Embedded Riley Slice Group
If you look closely, you can see one of our earlier pictures embedded in the limit set for the twice-punctured torus group. In the next picture we highlight in red the limit set for the subgroup generated by b and Aba, which is a free group generated by two parabolic elements, as in the Riley slice. The limit set is approximately a translation of the one appearing above under the title "Nearly Fuchsian".

Riley Slice group inside T_1,2 group

mu1 = mu2 = 2 i:
Click to enlarge

mu1 = mu2 = 2.1 i:
Click to enlarge

Maskit-Kra's T(1,3) (thrice-punctured tori)

These are free on four generators. Without explaining in detail the differences from the preceding situation, here are four examples. They are oddly similar to T_1,1 cases.

Maskit-Kra's T(0,5) (five-punctured spheres)

These are free on four generators:

a = [ 1 + mu1 , -mu1^2/2 ; 2 , 1 - mu1 ]
b = [ 1 , 2 ; 0 , 1]
c = [ 1 , 0 ; 2 , 1]
d = [ 1 + 2*mu2 , 2 ; -2*mu2^2 , 1 - 2*mu2 ]

Side-pairing for five-punctured sphere
mu1 = mu2 = 2.02 i:
Click to enlarge

mu1 = mu2 = .08 + 1.95 i:
Click to enlarge

Maskit-Kra's T(0,6) (six-punctured spheres)

These are free on five generators:

a = [ 1 -2*mu1 -2*mu1^2*mu2 , 2 + 4*mu1*mu2 + 2*mu1^2*mu2^2 ;
-2*mu1^2, 1+2*mu1+2*mu1^2*mu2 ]
b = [ 1 + 2*mu2 , -2*mu2^2 ; 2 , 1 - 2*mu2 ]
c = [ 1 , 2 ; 0 , 1]
d = [ 1 , 0 ; 2 , 1]
e = [ 1 + 2*mu3 , 2 ; -2*mu3^2 , 1 - 2*mu3 ]

Side-pairing for six-punctured sphere
mu1 = mu3 = 2.02 i, mu2= 1.25 i:
Click to enlarge

Cusp: mu1 = mu3 = 2 i, mu2= 1.25 i:
Click to enlarge

Embedded five-times punctured sphere
The above picture is a cusp where the six-punctured sphere has been deformed to a thrice-punctured sphere and a five-punctured sphere. The stabilizer of one of the components is now a quasifuchsian group representing a pair of five-punctured spheres. We have isolated one such subgroup generated by cB, cA, cE, and cD. The corresponding limit set (a simple closed curve) is highlighted in red.

Click here to see this picture

Maskit-Kra's T(2,1) (once-punctured genus two)

These are free on four generators:

a = i* [ mu1*mu2*mu3 + mu1 + mu2 , mu1*mu3 + 1 ; mu2*mu3 + 1 , mu3 ]
b = [ 1 + 2*mu1 , -2*mu1^2 ; 2 , 1 - 2*mu1]
c = [ -mu1*mu4 - mu4 - 1 , mu1*mu4 + mu4 - mu1 ; -mu4 , mu4 - 1]
d = [ 1 , 2 ; 0 , 1]

Side-pairing for once-punctured genus two
mu1 = mu2 = mu3 = mu4 = 2.02 i:
Click to enlarge

mu1 = mu2 = mu3 = mu4 = .08 + 1.95 i:
Click to enlarge

Pinching to a Cusp: mu1 = mu2 = mu3 = mu4 = 2 i:
Click to enlarge

At this cusp, the surface has had two curves pinched to points, resulting in a five-times punctured sphere. We see a set of equivalent components on which the group represents this 5-punctured sphere. The stabilizer of any of these components is a quasifuchsian group. We have highlighted in color the limit set of one such subgroup below.

Click to enlarge

The next picture has the corresponding domain completely colored in.

Click to enlarge

Based on the above illustrations, you may want to try to figure out generators for this subgroup and a side-pairing relation.

Click here for answer.

It is also instructive to identify fundamental regions on the above illustrations. We have identified limit points which serve as vertices for fundamental regions. You simply have to connect the dots in the right way.


David J. Wright (wrightd@math.okstate.edu)
Last modified: Fri Feb 28 12:48:47 CST 2003